Monday, 9 November 2020

Battle of Ellenbach 1758

Blogs are meant to be an up to date account of what the author is doing and thinking......but I fail miserably as I still have games from 2018 and 2019 I should be recording!......One day. But today  I am "up to date" as this was a lovely game which Ken Marshall and I managed to sneak in at the end of October just before Boris announced a new UK nationwide lockdown!

Ken offered to organise it and he came up with a battlefield sketch map which I did my best to recreate on my 8 x 6 table not knowing what it was. He asked for suggestions and I thought a bridge and roads leading to the village and hills would add flexibility. He instructed that the hills should be steep, the river impassable, and the woods only penetrable by light troops on foot.

I found out later that he had several ideas up his sleeve but on the day I opted for what he called the "standard attack and defence scenario" little knowing that this would turn out to be Ken's take on the battle of Sandershausen, between the French and Allies in 1758. Since we both have armies that are Imagi-nations, but heavily based on real regiments, he fielded a Prussian style force for the attacking "French" and I chose Hanoverians, with allied light troops for the "Allies". I hope this does not spoil the enjoyment of the historically-minded among my readers.

Ken moves forward the "Prussians"

For a good account of the real historical situation and Charles Grant and Phil Olley's refight of Sandershausen, which inspired Ken, please see Part Four of Charles Grant's "Wargaming in History, Volume 1". Below is our interpretation of the tabletop for our Battle of Ellenbach.  The bridge was broken in Ken's scenario so was removed for all the later photos.

In essence my smaller Allied force had been retreating but decided to stand to fight where the valley narrowed sufficiently to make the Prussian greater numbers less effective. To win I had to hold the enemy back for 8 Moves and get most of my force away intact ( less than 50% with 3 or more hits). Ken gave me the middle third of the table (lengthways) in which to set up. I quickly realised I could just make my main line of 3 good battalions stretch along the road in the gap between Ellenbach village and the river escarpment. I had my small Hussar regiment concealed in dead ground by the broken bridge (Unit 9 marker on later photos). A unit of light troops (Grenzers) was initially concealed on each flank in the woods on high ground forward of my first line. Much of my plan was inspired by Guildford Courthouse in the American War of Independence - classic three lines of which the first was mostly militia ordered to make a show of force but retreat before things got too hot. My third line was reasonably good troops - Horse Grenadiers we classed as dragoons, a Grenadier Battalion, and a medium battery on the hill where I could fire over my first two lines for a while.

Ken decided to try the same approach with his Jager units on each flank but decided to deploy his three brigades side by side in march columns and the heavy cavalry brigade in the rear. He later said he had planned on having more space to manoeuvre as he hadn't banked on me deploying "so far forward", Well, give me an inch etc.......
As usual we were using "Honours of War" rules, as published in the book with a few local amendments. Keith Flint advises on a 30cm gap between lines as realistic spacing which is why I had spread my three lines out and deployed forward.  You can see a PDF of Ken's instructions and orders of battle for both sides here Battle of Sandershausen or in the 18th Century Historical section in the Downloads sidebar.

So Ken arrived around 10 am and by 1100 we were all set up and ready to go......

A view of the Ken's Prussian Army's opening dispositions

.......and my Allied opposing army in three defensive lines

Today about 80% of the figures we used were from Ken's superb collection of Minden/Fife and Drum/Crann Tara 28mm

View from behind the Allied ranks. The Hanoverian Horse Grenadiers are my latest painted unit - RSM 95 figures. My first line has a Redoubt Miniatures "British" battalion flanked by Reikland Militia battalions made from Parkfield Miniatures Malburian range. My Hanoverian centre line battalions each had a battalion gun, extending "musket range" to 30 cm.

The action begins with skirmishing in the near woods and the Prussian right advancing. Poor Ken had rolled for a Dithering brigade commander in the centre and did not move forward, merely changing formation.

Infantry now begin to engage in the centre and my left front militia battalion bravely swings to face the advancing Prussian Grenadiers 

Jagers and Grenzers start a long term engagement on the highest ground but casualties were rare as both units were small and there was so much cover.

By Move Three the front line hotted up. I used a local rule amendment for the C-in-C to take command of one unit for a whole move and do nothing else but upgrade it to Dashing and lead it. So he led the left flank Militia battalion, which already had 3 Hits, in a mad charge on the Grenadiers. This charge was to buy time for my front line brigade commander who got a double move roll and was able to form columns and retreat as per my plan. See photo below.

As can be seen from this overall photo I was very lucky that the charging militia only got one more hit and so 4 forced them into a retreat rather than 5 which would have been "Done For" - just what I wanted really. Ken's lines are beginning to form but he hasn't got his artillery up yet and the cavalry are stuck just changing formation for lack of a better action to make!

Up in the woods my Grenzers gave way slowly as the first line fell back

On the other flank I'd had a couple of lucky rounds of fire and was able to keep the Jagers there at bay

By now my first line was falling back with the option to reform once the Militia got more than 60cm from the enemy in a safe place. With the battalion guns my second line was able to engage Ken's infantry early and inflicted casualties. My battery on the hill had forced the Prussian Grenadier battalion to retreat and turned its attention to the beautiful multi-line target on which I achieved a few Hits, including with cannon balls "grazing" fire. Ken was just beginning to get his own guns in action.

My retreating Militia battalion with a red circle marker to show it needs to reform before fighting again

It was not proving to be Ken's day unfortunately as he rolled a couple of 1s on successive moves when trying to mobilise his lovely Dragoon brigade

At this stage though the Prussian infantry line was beginning to look solid and a bit scary

However, by Move 6 I was beginning to get the better of the infantry firefights and with help from the artillery Ken's front line battalions began to waver and pull back

I had brought my Horse Grenadiers forward to add "support' if there was a melee but in the end they were not needed.

Ken's most significant success so far was a Hit on my battery which also caused
 material damage (shown by the little red die) and would deduct one from every
 subsequent score. I used that as the excuse for the battery to join my plan of retreat

Hits mounting up in the Prussian ranks are causing units to retreat and falling foul of those advancing Hussars. The Grenadiers have rallied, reformed and are back though 

Ken makes one of many good points and below his hands a Prussian battalion is about to meet its high water mark. On both flanks my Grenzers had pulled back to try to protect the end of the main line. Note my Unit 9  Hussars are just about still concealed by the hill slope

But just when they might have been revealed they rolled for a double move which gave me ample distance to manoeuvre and charge the flank of the advancing Prussians, who were taken by surprise with not enough warning to turn to face.

But those Prussians remained in line facing front only to be broken by severe musket and battalion gun fire from my right flank Hanoverian battalion. 

Now my Hussars were without a target and we used the melee cavalry follow up rules to see what they did.  Come on! Hussars with fleeing men in front? - they carried on of course,  sabres waving in glee to slam into the line of bayonets of the Prussian fusiliers and were themselves broken!

Well that was my last photo because all that happened in Move 8 was me pulling back the second and third lines further, fleeing the Hussars down the side by the river woods, and continuing the retreat towards my objective with the Militia brigade. On my left flank the Grenz unit held Ellenbach village thus intimidating a full Prussian pursuit on that side. Ken's troops looked a bit chaotic and not in a position to make quick progress.

It was 6pm and time to pack up and we had achieved Ken's 8 Move target. There was not much doubt about the winner. I'd had a few lucky breaks and exploited them while Ken had hindered himself by not deploying his guns early enough or allowing the cavalry a way through to the front. Apart from a few unlucky initiative dice you could say he was defeated by his own numbers and the bottleneck of my position. Nevertheless we both enjoyed the day immensely. We had not seen each other for over a year (there was a lot to catch up on at the pub at lunchtime) but we played at a gentlemanly and fairly leisurely pace enjoying the spectacle of a relatively simple scenario but with great variation and depth to how it could play. I do recommend you look at Ken's adaptation of this battle for HoW in my sidebar, give it a go yourselves and let us know how it plays.

Thank you Ken for all your efforts and this was a great way to get my 18th Century "fix" before a second lockdown.


  1. Always wonderful reading your posts Chris. Tremendous looking battle.

  2. A delightful AAR. Thanks for sharing this

  3. Super looking set-up.

    As for the battle site, I think we've all been there ;-)

  4. Wonderful lines of battle Chris, what a great looking game!

  5. Carlo, Doug, Phil and Nundanket thank you all so much for your great comments. Yes indeed I loved having the opportunity to deploy "historically" in the space even though the armies were small.

  6. Excellent report and great to see those lines marching across the table.

  7. Superb looking game, a joy to look at and read the AAR, really inspirational.

  8. Superb looking game and a splendid day had by all it seems. Huzzah!

  9. Excellent post Chris, fantastic photo's. Thanks for sharing.

    Stay safe and happy gaming,

  10. Greg, Paul and Willz thank you as always for your unfailing support for my blogging, it's a treat to have your comments. Donnie, thanks, if I can "inspire" someone with my wargaming blog it makes my day.

  11. Hey Chris, great looking collection and game as per usual. A great set of rules for 18th century too which I have enjoyed on a number of occasions at yours. Keep the fifes piping and the drummers drumming! Tally ho - till next time........whenever that might be!!

    1. Thanks for stopping by Kevin, yes I'm looking forward to having you here again - maybe as soon as our joint birthdays hopefully

  12. Great stuff Chris. Looks as though you both had a good scrap. I haven't had a game since March which is all the more frustrating as one of my friends lives in the next road. I'm getting lots of painting done though and whittling away at my lead mountain.

    1. Thanks Tony. Ken is a gentleman to play against so most of his troops were on the "scrap" heap rather than min :-) Sorry you have been gameless and good luck with the lead mountain, I'm doing a bit of that too - those Hanoverian Horse Grenadiers are the first in about 240 Hanoverian RSM 95 cav and inf.

  13. Well done Chris and great to hear from you.

    1. Thanks and from you Robbie, sorry I have not been posting more frequently I will try to do better.

  14. Blogger has prevented my friend Oscar from posting a comment so here it is "Awesome as always! I tried to leave a post again but failed!?! Doesn’t let me log in via google..." Thanks Oscar

  15. Apologies Chris but I missed this, I've either been asleep or busy! Another excellent write up and a superb looking table as is usual

    1. Better late than never Kerry, thank you for stopping by and your never failing support. It's my fault really as I have been posting so rarely you have got out of the habit of visiting!

  16. Wonderful looking game and blog.

    1. Many thanks Your Excellency, for your visit and supportive comments

  17. What a beautiful looking battle! And I'm glad to see "the good guys" won too. :-)



    1. David thank you very much. It's sort of Imagi-Nations so I'm never sure who the good guys are!